by John Maddox Roberts
1985 Tor
Two barbarians fight it out in the Sword and Sorcery match in the Fantasy division.
Had to write this quick, as I'm already beginning to confuse the two barbarians who both get magic swords from sorcerers and go on quests. Fox's prose was better and his stories had a bit more of an edge to them, but (odd coming from me) the pieces were under written. While epic fantasy takes too long to get from point A to point B, here I had some problems following what little story there was.
Carter's prose was a titch immature, though not always a bad thing for this kind of story. His action scenes were more blow for blow than Fox's and the novel format benefited the series of scenes which could have been disjointed short stories.
I would say Kothar was better written, but Thongor was more fun to read. Thongor moves up in the Fantasy division!

Thongor and the Wizard of Lemuria
by Lin Carter
1969 Berkley


Thongor is a young barbarian in ancient Lemuria. He kills an officer in a bar fight, is arrested, escapes, steals an airship, is attacked by flying reptile birds, crashes, and is rescued by a sorcerer. The sorcerer has a quest - to forge a sword from a fallen star to defeat the ritual of sorcerers descended from dinosaurs. Along the way he gets captured and escapes at least four times, picking up another fighter and a princess as companions.
A fun read, lots of adventure and action, plenty of monsters, though the pulpy pace leaves out a lot of descriptions, leaving you guessing what a lot of these monsters look like. Unlike Conan, Thongor is explicitly decked out in Frazetta fashion, with a loincloth and leather harness. He wakes up naked after being dropped in a giant reptile-eagle nest, so I can only assume he was naked through the rest of the book.
A fun, short read that probably covers as much ground as a 800 page epic fantasy. Somehow, the first version of this from 1966 was even shorter.
